Predicting future performance – revisited

A long time ago I took a look at a range of statistics to determine which was the best predictor of future performance. I did this by looking at the performance of a team one season and seeing which statistic showed the least regression towards the mean.

I now have a much larger data set (702 sets of back-to-back seasons) on which to base a more concrete conclusion and the results are as follows. The initial post demonstrated that using ratio’s (such as shots on target ratio) regress far less to the mean than differential or pythagorian values and so these are what I will report. The updated table appears as follows:

Factor R2 Regression towards the mean
Goals 0.332 42.4%
Shots on target 0.462 32.1%
Total shots 0.473 31.2%
Sh% 0.109 66.9%
Sv% 0.128 64.2%
PDO 0.067 74.1%

To give these values a bit of context, the points a team earns regress ~47.8% towards the mean over consecutive seasons (it’s important to note that I didn’t include seasons where teams were promoted or relegated so the inevitable drop off/improvement the following year). Therefore if we want to know how a team will perform in the future then using points is less accurate than goals or shots.

Two of the ratio’s clearly stand out as being much better at predicting future performance than the rest. In this case it turns out that the best predictor is in fact the ratio of the total shots in the games a team plays. From now on (as in the few posts that remain) I’ll switch to use total shots ratio to predict future performance.

Finally I threw sh%, sv% and PDO in there to once again reiterate just how much they fluctuate from season to season. All three of these are vastly more luck driven than skill driven.

5 thoughts on “Predicting future performance – revisited

  1. Pingback: Winning matches, is it luck or skill? | 11tegen11

  2. Pingback: Shot Ratios and PDO in the SPL | The Celtic View

  3. Pingback: 11tegen11 | Predicting the final Eredivisie league table

  4. Pingback: Not just a tiebreaker: what goal difference tells us « 5 Added Minutes

  5. Pingback: Why I don’t board the PSV bandwagon just yet | 11tegen11

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s